|
Need Cash? Call a Hedge Fund
Some Young Tech Companies Move Beyond
Venture Capital; 'Email Me When You Go Public'
By Rebecca Buckman
VentureWire
Wednesday, April 5, 2006
When fast-growing technology company Pay By Touch went looking
for cash slightly over a year ago, it met with private-equity
firms and venture capitalists.
But the closely held San Francisco firm wound up taking money
from a different type of investor: hedge funds.
Pay By Touch makes biometric identification gizmos that read
fingerprints so shoppers can automatically pay for what they
buy out of bank or credit accounts. Giant hedge funds, including
Farallon Capital Management and Och-Ziff Capital Management,
helped it raise $130 million in September.
About two months ago, the company, whose official name is
Solidus Networks Inc. but does business as Pay By Touch, snared
another $60 million, about half of it from hedge funds. These
lightly regulated investment vehicles typically invest in
publicly traded stocks and other liquid assets rather than
private companies.
"There's not a company around that wouldn't want to do what
we've done," says Pay By Touch Chief Executive John Rogers,
who says investors view the company as being about a year
away from an initial public offering of stock. Hedge funds
often make quicker investment decisions than venture capitalists
and can offer more money -- though some say they may not scrutinize
private companies enough before investing.
Farallon declined to comment, and Och-Ziff didn't return
a call seeking comment.
Shoppers use a Pay By Touch at a Piggly Wiggly store in South
Carolina. Hedge funds financed it.
As other private firms wait for the moribund market for venture-backed
IPOs to open up, they also are starting to tap the pool of
hedge-fund cash. Microbia Inc., a Cambridge, Mass., pharmaceutical
company, raised $75 million in February, a little less than
a third of it from two hedge funds. ITA Software Inc., a Cambridge,
Mass., maker of software for the airline industry, raised
$100 million in January from a syndicate including three venture-capital
firms, a buyout firm and a hedge fund. Just this week, another
Massachusetts drug company, Merrimack Pharmaceuticals Inc.,
said it collected about half its latest, $65 million funding
round from hedge funds.
Because hedge funds tend to be secretive, there are no estimates
of the total they have invested in private start-up companies.
In some ways the trend is a replay of the late 1990s, when
hedge funds also moved into the venture arena, with mixed
success, clamoring for cheap shares of private companies,
including hot dot-coms, right before they went public.
The difference today is that it's more difficult to take
small high-tech companies public. Hedge funds now are mainly
trying to deploy the enormous amounts of capital they have
raised over the last several years and diversify their investments,
since returns haven't been stellar for most public stocks.
Hedge funds currently have an estimated $1.5 trillion under
management world-wide, compared with about $261 billion for
venture-capital firms in the U.S., according to data from
HedgeFund Intelligence Ltd. and the U.S. National Venture
Capital Association.
Investing in private companies has risks -- for the hedge
funds, for the companies they invest in, and for venture capitalists,
who already are competing furiously for deals. "These guys
could shift 5% of their money into venture and swamp VCs,"
says Kate Mitchell, a managing director with BA Venture Partners
in Foster City, Calif. They could "massively overfund" small
companies, she says, thus reducing returns for everyone.
Paying Down Debt
Some venture capitalists say hedge funds now are willing
to make investments of $20 million to $30 million, not an
unusual size for a later-stage, venture-capital deal. Some
hedge funds take equity stakes in firms just as venture investors
have done.
Hedge funds sometimes provide financing in the form of loans
or special debt securities, which start-ups could have trouble
paying down. Having debt on the books also could make it tougher
for start-ups to attract other investors if they don't grow
as expected. Some money Pay By Touch raised from hedge funds
last year came in the form of convertible debt and senior
notes. Pay By Touch's chief financial officer, Gus Spanos,
says that kind of funding "does carry more risk" than selling
an equity stake but "we're comfortable with the trade-off."
For private companies, hedge-fund investments can be very
alluring. Because the funds typically make many more investments
than venture-capital firms, they can offer capital at attractive
prices and don't depend as much on outsized returns to make
up for the many failures of small companies. Hedge-fund managers,
accustomed to darting quickly in and out of stock positions,
also have a reputation for making investment decisions quickly
-- another plus for private companies anxious to snare cash.
Venture capitalists often can't compete with hedge funds
that value private companies more richly. "It's happened to
everybody," says Bruce Evans, a managing partner at Summit
Partners in Boston, which does venture capital and larger
buyouts. Also, debt financing can prevent further dilution
of founders' stakes in their own companies, if hedge funds
don't take equity stakes. Mature companies that succeed in
robust markets can do well by taking hedge-fund money, investors
and academics say.
And hedge funds often have a more relaxed management style.
A venture capitalist "might be camping out in your conference
room, asking all kinds of annoying questions," says Bill Burnham,
a former managing director with Mobius Venture Capital who
is now a private investor. The attitude of a hedge-fund manager,
he says, might be, "Here's your check -- email me when you
go public."
A Need to Nurture
Still, hedge funds generally don't have much experience dealing
with small, private firms, which often need nurturing to succeed.
As short-term investors, hedge funds might not stick with
an investment for years as a company matures, as venture capitalists
do.
"Hedge funds will be fickle," says William Sahlman, a professor
specializing in entrepreneurial management at Harvard Business
School. "If a few successes occur, money will pour in quickly....A
few disasters, on the other hand, will stop the practice overnight."
Unlike venture capitalists, who generally wait to take profits
themselves until they have actually realized gains on an investment,
such as through an IPO or sale of a company, hedge funds often
take profits from investments once a year, based on estimated
gains. So if hedge funds overvalue private-company investments
-- a process that can be subjective -- their long-term investors
could lose out if the investments ultimately crash and burn.
Some hedge funds are adopting new valuation rules to deal
with these situations.
If start-up founders believe "all money is green, so whoever
pays them the highest price wins," they may go to a hedge
fund for financing, says Tom Crotty, a general partner with
Battery Ventures in Wellesley, Mass. He says most young firms
will pay extra for the advice and connections of venture-capital
firms.

|